Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 26

Thread: BIG CAM TUNING ON LT1. Let's talk idle tuning

  1. #1
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604

    BIG CAM TUNING ON LT1. Let's talk idle tuning

    So like the title says. I have a big cam in an LT1 Camaro. I set the minimum spark to 5 degrees and it pretty much just stays there (did this to prevent negative timing) The car chops okay now but should chop harder for a cam of this size. Looking to get the spark to swing a bit. I noticed on a few other 1le Camaros they don't make much spark at idle for whatever reason even before the cam. So I'm a little worried it might not be possible for some reason.
    I know you really need the torque numbers at idle to be perfect. What are your target numbers for a big cam?
    Attached Files Attached Files

  2. #2
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2022
    Posts
    17
    What is the cam? I have a fairly large cam in my LT1 231/246, .635/.635, 114 LSA 111 ICl. Timing swings from 4-16 degrees.

    Idle tab > adaptive and predicted; add 10% - 20% to get more chop. There is a point where drivability suffers. I found adding 20% made my car chop pretty good.

  3. #3
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604
    240/252 112lsa I need more work on the VTT tables. They can't be to far off because the car is holding the idle I'm requesting. It's just not getting any timing. It idle what are your torque read outs looking like?

  4. #4
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    Your torque on the left hand side of the log is ideal, but the right side after it starts fluctuating is quite a bit different. Your idle is stabil because of how you have your airmass side dipped. This focus's the torque to a specific area. I'm honestly surprised you don't have hot start slow rev to idle problems with the way you have it shaped. If you have a stock log for your car that's best to go by for how to shift the tm to best suite the new cam. Usually works, but not always. I've got some 2ss's where they're idling with -5 or -6 lbft if that'll help you. Personally I like to target something around 0 to 10 with hot idle and no load and something around 20 with load in idle.
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  5. #5
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Arizona
    Posts
    217
    Quote Originally Posted by JASON11WS6 View Post
    240/252 112lsa I need more work on the VTT tables. They can't be to far off because the car is holding the idle I'm requesting. It's just not getting any timing. It idle what are your torque read outs looking like?
    Iron out your VVE and timing should come back in line.
    2009.5 PBM G8 GXP M6 W/Roof-Self tune, OBX LTs, Kooks axleback, LSA blower, cam,
    Monster LT1-SC clutch, flex fuel, 12 psi [email protected] 1,800 D.A
    2007 TBSS-Self tune, bolt ons [email protected], 1,900 D.A
    1991 GMC Syclone- Self tune/catback 12.8@104, 4,200ft D.A

  6. #6
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    Quote Originally Posted by STAGEUP View Post
    Iron out your VVE and timing should come back in line.
    I didn't even look at that. Yes, this will change everything so best to do that first then work on the torque model.
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  7. #7
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604
    Tuned the ve in and I'm still dealing with negative timing. If I force the timing to a positive number it swings a bit.

  8. #8
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    Post the current tune and a log
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  9. #9
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604
    JUICED.1LE.J.ATTACK.009idle.hplJUICED.1LE..J.ATTACK.CAM.009.hpt

    Even with the negative timing it still sounds decent. Not sure if I can deal with the glowing red headers though.

    Where do you guys usually want your torque numbers at during idle? 0-20 ft/lbs I was always told.

  10. #10
    Senior Tuner
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    2,608
    Quote Originally Posted by JASON11WS6 View Post
    Tuned the ve in and I'm still dealing with negative timing. If I force the timing to a positive number it swings a bit.
    The last cammed LT1 I did I purposely didn't touch any torque stuff till the end. I still think Qsubc x fuel flow is the driving thing on torque calculations


    Anyway.. With no virtual torque edits at all but with a MAF failed and VVE tuned, and re enabled MAF the idle timing was a normal 12-18 degrees at an idle.


    I disagree with the consensus on this board with the idea that VVE can be backed out from MAF. I've written my own equation, I've used the ones posted here. The signal is just too noisy to be accurate with it in most cases. That is just my experience.. use it how you want. I do this every day M-F 9-5 and I can say that yeah I've had cars I've gotten OK results with but I get great results each time failing MAF.
    Tuner at PCMofnc.com
    Email tuning!!!, Mail order, Dyno tuning, Performance Parts, Electric Fan Kits, 4l80e swap harnesses, 6l80 -> 4l80e conversion harnesses, Installs

  11. #11
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    While I do agree with a large majority of what Alvin said, that doesn't necessarily apply to big cams. Even smallish cams after they get to a certain point require remapping the torque model to a degree and yes as I've personally always stated EVERYTHING that effects fueling will affect the torque calcs. I personally have had my customers fail the MAF to double check maths. At least the maths I use are nearly always within a couple of percent, but I do try to make them log with slow pedal movements - seems to make a big difference on the calcs.

    I use two different ones on the calcs. The first uses airmass and should get you within 10% or less the first pass. I then switch over to the VE error calc which solely uses MAF and fueling errors to get it within a couple of percent. It does take a few passes and if anything is off causing fuel to shift then so will these. Just using the VE error calc, it's saying your VE is off about 1%, but again this will change slightly with the timing causing fuel to change.

    (([50041.223]*(273.15+[50011.241]) * (1000/[50030.91]))
    100 * ((([50040.71] * ([50114.156] + [50116.156])) - [2311.71]) / [50040.71]

    Get another idle log only with this one. Don't drive with it. Just checking the changes and it still needs a lot of work. As long as you have positive timing now get a 10 min idle log so it'll learn the new settings.
    Attached Files Attached Files
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  12. #12
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604
    Timing was still negative. I let it run for a minute or two but the headers are gonna start glowing red and burning up wires soon so I shut it down.
    Attached Files Attached Files

  13. #13
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    Idle torque wasn't that far off. Good chance you need to reset everything. Unhook the battery and do a global power down. Load this one after hooking the battery back up then let me know. Also did you tune the VVE with maf failed or with a math? It shouldn't be that far off, but nonetheless.
    Attached Files Attached Files
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  14. #14
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Posts
    604
    I did a failed maf for the vve tuning. I held my food on the pedal during this scan just to keep the timing positive for a little while. Otherwise it stayed negative.
    Attached Files Attached Files

  15. #15
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    Had to look at some other stock logs. Doesn't look like I shifted the airmass side enough. This one should be closer to stock.

    AND you did do a global power down - unhooked and touched pos cable to neg post? Then did a throttle reset with the scanner and other usual resets?

    Again this torque model is only for idle testing - don't drive on it.
    Attached Files Attached Files
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  16. #16
    Senior Tuner
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    South FL
    Posts
    1,359
    I know I'm late to the party but ill give some feedback even though I see Ghuggins is helping you get on track.

    I have had to make crazy looking Virtual Torque tables just to get a car to pass the throttle learn test. Then I was able to resort back to a more reasonable VT table. It was very strange but that was the only way I could get one car to idle in the positive. In hindsight I think I could have just skipped to my method below as I haven't had this issue again since.

    But in general, if you're having low idle timing issues, you want the car to close the throttle blade more. To get the car to close the throttle blade more you have to tell it that its making MORE torque at idle. But WAIT, weren't we taught we need to reduce the VT to fix this? Yup and that works in some cases lol. This is why its confusing.

    What I have done is lower the VT a bit, lower the VVE a bit(your VVE needs to be reset and start over), but increase the MAF in the idle area until the timing starts to come up. It's basically like you have to rescale the amount of torque(airflow) that counts towards combustion without having the controls to do so. So by telling it its making less torque via VT & VVE, but then telling the MAF its seeing more air(more torque) it sort of rescales the range in the throttle for idle. Also, you can't have any sort of crazy Throttle Area values. Maybe increase this by 10% at most. I have stage 2 heads cam cars running around with the stock throttle area scalar.

    As for chop, this is two part. First you need it to idle with the correct timing and airflow. Second you set the chop in the adaptive idle area in the immediate(spark) table.


    How big a cam is this?
    [email protected]
    Owner/GM Calibrator
    Gen V Specialist - C7 Corvette, Gen6 Camaro & CTS-V3

  17. #17
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    It shows to be idling in the 80kpa range, but throttle and timing will change all of that and the resulting torque model.

    I've never tried raising the MAF to force it to learn. Is there a percentage you overshoot it Jason? I have used a "general" torque model that I throw into them making the idle torque REALLY negative that seems to force them to shift. I like the MAF idea better......

    I should have his torque model somewhat close in the idle region for a big cam - at least to match where his "stock" settings were - it still needs blending back to stockish for driving and curving for cranking, but other than that it should be somewhat close for idle. His map changes do favor his VVE, so it's possible his VVE is close. I've never seen one like that even with big cams, but...
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  18. #18
    Senior Tuner
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    South FL
    Posts
    1,359
    Quote Originally Posted by GHuggins View Post
    It shows to be idling in the 80kpa range, but throttle and timing will change all of that and the resulting torque model.

    I've never tried raising the MAF to force it to learn. Is there a percentage you overshoot it Jason? I have used a "general" torque model that I throw into them making the idle torque REALLY negative that seems to force them to shift. I like the MAF idea better......

    I should have his torque model somewhat close in the idle region for a big cam - at least to match where his "stock" settings were - it still needs blending back to stockish for driving and curving for cranking, but other than that it should be somewhat close for idle. His map changes do favor his VVE, so it's possible his VVE is close. I've never seen one like that even with big cams, but...
    I usually aim for 8-12% negative fuel trims at idle. Then I pull the VT down by a fixed number on the first three columns, like say 20-70 by adding a negative value and then interpolating to the right. I apply the same to the MAF and MAP VT and I look and see where I am at. Sometimes this works great but sometimes you have to jump into the VVE table. What's strange is when you lower the Virtual Torque values the MAF values and MAP values hold a different weight when changing. I mean I guess it makes sense as its part of a calculation. And if you lower the Virtua Torque, that tells the equation that each gram of air makes less power. But then you add to your MAF and VVE and that tells the ECU that more air is coming in. I've had to mess with this ratio to get idle to play nice on some cams.

    If you want the throttle to close more at idle to gain some timing back, you tell the ECU that you're making less torque at idle in the VT tables. But then you tell it your ingesting more air via the MAF table. Then the throttle starts to behave better and close and put some timing back in. I've also reduced Virtual Torque in the MAP tables and increased VVE to get the initial off idle throttle to not stumble. I'm probably doing a poor job of explaining this. I think about it like this which is actually old school thinking. The Virtual Torque is essentially saying how much of the incoming air is being used for combustion which then equals X power. The MAF and MAP are saying what the measured airmass coming in is. In the old days tuning VE was basically saying X amount means X percent of the incoming air measured is used for effective combustion resulting in created power. So compared to Gen 3 days, lowering VT and increasing the MAF/MAP would be the same as going into the VE table of a Gen 3 and lowering it to tell it that it is less efficient, yet the ECU was seeing more air through the MAF sensor.

    lol....I hope I made sense of what I'm trying to say. I don't have it all figured out here, just sharing my experiences and thought process.
    [email protected]
    Owner/GM Calibrator
    Gen V Specialist - C7 Corvette, Gen6 Camaro & CTS-V3

  19. #19
    Tuning Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Location
    Franklin, NC / Gainesville, Ga
    Posts
    6,736
    OK, so basically - at least as far as the making the ecm recalibrate itself - add 10ish percent to the MAF curve and force it to relearn things? Is there a given time period you let it idle like this to force the throttle recalibration process?

    I have also found that by lowering DD idle cell (only to a point) and raising reserve will help bring timing up, but you have to find the balance to where everything is happy. On the ones where it's adjustable - if the DD idle cell torque is too high, such as the stock value on trucks - it can force negative timing to try and get torque up - if that makes sense? Usually cars have this set about right for cams, so not a big necessity to adjust.
    2010 Vette Stock Bottom LS3 - LS2 APS Twin Turbo Kit, Trick Flow Heads and Custom Cam - 12psi - 714rwhp and 820rwtq / 100hp Nitrous Shot starting at 3000 rpms - 948rwhp and 1044rwtq still on 93
    2011 Vette Cam Only Internal Mod in stock LS3 -- YSI @ 18psi - 811rwhp on 93 / 926rwhp on E60 & 1008rwhp with a 50 shot of nitrous all through a 6L80

    ~Greg Huggins~
    Remote Tuning Available at gh[email protected]
    Mobile Tuning Available for North Georgia and WNC

  20. #20
    Senior Tuner
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Location
    South FL
    Posts
    1,359
    Quote Originally Posted by GHuggins View Post
    OK, so basically - at least as far as the making the ecm recalibrate itself - add 10ish percent to the MAF curve and force it to relearn things? Is there a given time period you let it idle like this to force the throttle recalibration process?

    I have also found that by lowering DD idle cell (only to a point) and raising reserve will help bring timing up, but you have to find the balance to where everything is happy. On the ones where it's adjustable - if the DD idle cell torque is too high, such as the stock value on trucks - it can force negative timing to try and get torque up - if that makes sense? Usually cars have this set about right for cams, so not a big necessity to adjust.

    I had to drop the Virtual Torque below where I would normally have set it, then ramped up the MAF. Then I did a cold start idle for 3 minutes, drove the car and it seemed to be better. Then let the car sit, did another mostly cold start and short drive. By the third cold start the car passed the throttle learn as the code(which doesn't set a CEL) was no longer listed when I pulled the codes. The car idled with positive timing. I flashed the Virtual Torque back but only pulled the MAF down just a little bit and the car has been fine since. This particular car has the LTFT enabled and they range from -8%-13% or so depending on weather. It isn't where I would normally leave the MAF, but its working for this car.
    [email protected]
    Owner/GM Calibrator
    Gen V Specialist - C7 Corvette, Gen6 Camaro & CTS-V3