Page 5 of 5 FirstFirst 12345
Results 81 to 97 of 97

Thread: RWTD - I took your suggestion on MAF only CL

  1. #81
    I am going to try this

  2. #82
    Tuner in Training 1genls2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    42
    402 ls2 forged internals, 11.0 to 1, 90mm FAST intake with Nick Willams tb, Patriot heads, SLP under drive pulley, Areomotive fuel rail / A1000 pump and regulator,Comp 248/254 114 lsa .622 .612, Stainless Works Long tube headers with 3 inch all the way out with x-pipe, Miezere water pump, 6 speed, 9 inch rear end.

    Oh yeah, stock injectors. 1999 vcm

    Take a look at this log I ran tonight, I put the Hi/Lo thresh a 0 like you said and ran it. I did run better. It is getting closer, thanks again for your time I DO APPERICATE IT.
    Last edited by 1genls2; 07-25-2009 at 11:21 PM. Reason: more info
    1967 camaro LS2/M6
    2001 Formula LS1/A4

  3. #83
    Advanced Tuner 69lt1bird's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    983
    That looks like a great combo, it should haul

    Post your tune up and the config file for the log file.

    What injectors are you using?
    Do you have a wideband hooked up?
    Last edited by 69lt1bird; 07-26-2009 at 08:18 AM.
    Free HP Tuners Beginners Tuning Guide

    LS1 Tuning Guide
    Michigan Snowmobiler

    1969 Firebird: 11.67@114 [email protected] 1/8 1.70 60 ft. EPS cam 234/246 .602.606 114+3, 6.0 LQ4, L92 heads milled 10.5:1, Ported L76 intake, ported 90mm Holley TB, 100mm MAF, FIC Custom injectors, Hooker LT, PYPES dual exhaust with an X pipe, 4L65e with all of the good parts inside, FTI 4000 RPM Stall, 12 bolt with 3.73 gears. HP Tuner tuned by me

  4. #84
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Portersville, Pa
    Posts
    289
    I have a question on the MAF only tuning. The last 3 cars I tuned w/HPT were Gen4 with the VVE. By far the MAF only tune was easier than trying to tune both the VVE and the MAF. In fact you have to almost be a mathematician to properly tune the VVE and have many hours to waste/bill the customer. The MAF only tunes (both OL and CL) ran great and were done in several hours.

    My Question: The last car to be tuned was an LS2 in a 2009 GTM. I left the PE disabled on this particular tune since the time spent on the MAF calibration seemed to yield excellent results on the loaded dyno including cruising and WOT from various speeds (including idle) and various gears. The car ran out of fuel (no fuel gauge yet) after numerous pulls with great fueling and I decided to leave it this way. I had intended to reenable the PE and make a few additional pulls but why?

    Thoughts?

  5. #85
    Advanced Tuner 69lt1bird's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    983
    Because you did not tune it correctly. Set the PE table to your desired Commanded AFR for WOT and then tune the MAF. DO NOT DISABLE THE PE TABLE.
    Free HP Tuners Beginners Tuning Guide

    LS1 Tuning Guide
    Michigan Snowmobiler

    1969 Firebird: 11.67@114 [email protected] 1/8 1.70 60 ft. EPS cam 234/246 .602.606 114+3, 6.0 LQ4, L92 heads milled 10.5:1, Ported L76 intake, ported 90mm Holley TB, 100mm MAF, FIC Custom injectors, Hooker LT, PYPES dual exhaust with an X pipe, 4L65e with all of the good parts inside, FTI 4000 RPM Stall, 12 bolt with 3.73 gears. HP Tuner tuned by me

  6. #86
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Portersville, Pa
    Posts
    289
    Quote Originally Posted by 69lt1bird View Post
    Because you did not tune it correctly. Set the PE table to your desired Commanded AFR for WOT and then tune the MAF. DO NOT DISABLE THE PE TABLE.
    Thanks for the input. I am new to HPT and trying to learn this process and test the affect of different modifications. The first two cars were tuned the way you suggested (i set the PE to 1.157) and tuned the MAF from there. However, I am not sure that it actually made much of a difference in the tune by disabling the PE and then tuning off the MAF alone. I can tell you for certain that the fuel curves are spot on regardless of starting speed to WOT and regardless of gear. Unless of course if setting PE Enable MAP to 256kpa doesn't actually disable the PE? Can you be more specific as to why I didn't tune it correctly?

    Also, I was thinking (and may be mistaken) that I should try tune the MAF without any modifiers and then set the PE to my desired A/F at WOT and the ECU would use this information to correct the fueling if necessary.

    Thanks,
    Mike
    Last edited by [email protected]; 07-26-2009 at 05:43 PM.

  7. #87
    Tuner in Training 1genls2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    42
    Stock injectors for now, I pulled out the FAST 36 lb's thinking they are to much. Now I understand that they werent the problem! no wideband.

    I am new to HPT and this is my first tune.... Take a look.
    1967 camaro LS2/M6
    2001 Formula LS1/A4

  8. #88
    Advanced Tuner 69lt1bird's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    983
    First things first. You put thousands into that engine and you are trying to tune it without a wideband, STOP until you get one. $250 is cheap compared to what you already spent. Tuning without one on a bolt on car is one thing, a big cammed car, hell no.

    Once you get the wideband, your tune file needs a lot of attention, nothing too major, but just a lot of small stuff.
    Free HP Tuners Beginners Tuning Guide

    LS1 Tuning Guide
    Michigan Snowmobiler

    1969 Firebird: 11.67@114 [email protected] 1/8 1.70 60 ft. EPS cam 234/246 .602.606 114+3, 6.0 LQ4, L92 heads milled 10.5:1, Ported L76 intake, ported 90mm Holley TB, 100mm MAF, FIC Custom injectors, Hooker LT, PYPES dual exhaust with an X pipe, 4L65e with all of the good parts inside, FTI 4000 RPM Stall, 12 bolt with 3.73 gears. HP Tuner tuned by me

  9. #89
    Tuner in Training 1genls2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    42
    Done. What is your preference? It will be on the way. I always wanted to get one, but didn't know what to buy.
    1967 camaro LS2/M6
    2001 Formula LS1/A4

  10. #90
    Senior Tuner Frost's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Richmond VA
    Posts
    1,950
    Quote Originally Posted by 69lt1bird View Post
    Because you did not tune it correctly. Set the PE table to your desired Commanded AFR for WOT and then tune the MAF. DO NOT DISABLE THE PE TABLE.

    If you run OL, you just command high load fueling appropriately in the OLFA. If I tune FOR OL, this is the table I use to command fueling everywhere and leave PE disabled.
    Steve Williams
    TunedbyFrost.com


  11. #91
    Advanced Tuner 69lt1bird's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    983
    Frost, that is good to know but it doesn't sound like he is leaving it in open loop.
    Free HP Tuners Beginners Tuning Guide

    LS1 Tuning Guide
    Michigan Snowmobiler

    1969 Firebird: 11.67@114 [email protected] 1/8 1.70 60 ft. EPS cam 234/246 .602.606 114+3, 6.0 LQ4, L92 heads milled 10.5:1, Ported L76 intake, ported 90mm Holley TB, 100mm MAF, FIC Custom injectors, Hooker LT, PYPES dual exhaust with an X pipe, 4L65e with all of the good parts inside, FTI 4000 RPM Stall, 12 bolt with 3.73 gears. HP Tuner tuned by me

  12. #92
    Advanced Tuner 69lt1bird's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    983
    Quote Originally Posted by 1genls2 View Post
    Done. What is your preference? It will be on the way. I always wanted to get one, but didn't know what to buy.
    NGK AFX
    http://www.ngksparkplugs.com/product...rmance/afx.asp
    Free HP Tuners Beginners Tuning Guide

    LS1 Tuning Guide
    Michigan Snowmobiler

    1969 Firebird: 11.67@114 [email protected] 1/8 1.70 60 ft. EPS cam 234/246 .602.606 114+3, 6.0 LQ4, L92 heads milled 10.5:1, Ported L76 intake, ported 90mm Holley TB, 100mm MAF, FIC Custom injectors, Hooker LT, PYPES dual exhaust with an X pipe, 4L65e with all of the good parts inside, FTI 4000 RPM Stall, 12 bolt with 3.73 gears. HP Tuner tuned by me

  13. #93
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Portersville, Pa
    Posts
    289
    Quote Originally Posted by 69lt1bird View Post
    Because you did not tune it correctly. Set the PE table to your desired Commanded AFR for WOT and then tune the MAF. DO NOT DISABLE THE PE TABLE.
    Just an FYI, I disabled CL and enabled PE and it made no difference in the A/F, horsepower, torque, timing etc. It did however allow me to easily manipulate the A/F by changing the EQ Ratio rather than the MAF airflow.

    So for reference, I'm not sure that disabling the PE table when the remainder of the tune accounts for acceleration enrichment makes much difference.

  14. #94
    Advanced Tuner blownbluez06's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Forney, TX
    Posts
    982
    Quote Originally Posted by [email protected] View Post
    Just an FYI, I disabled CL and enabled PE and it made no difference in the A/F, horsepower, torque, timing etc. It did however allow me to easily manipulate the A/F by changing the EQ Ratio rather than the MAF airflow.

    So for reference, I'm not sure that disabling the PE table when the remainder of the tune accounts for acceleration enrichment makes much difference.
    If you enabled what you thought was disabling PE and it made no difference, then I don't see how it could have been disabled in the first place.
    Frost, why would you manipulate the EQ ratio table to get your fueling straight unless the reason your fueling was off was temperature based?
    Hsquared racing engines RHS 427, Procharger F2, Moran Billet Atomizer injectors, Alky Control,Mast LS7 heads, Nitrous outlet kit,Tilton quad disc clutch, DSS shaft, RKT56 ZR1 trans, RPM Quaife diff. Built and tuned by yours truly.

  15. #95
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Portersville, Pa
    Posts
    289
    Quote Originally Posted by blownbluez06 View Post
    If you enabled what you thought was disabling PE and it made no difference, then I don't see how it could have been disabled in the first place.
    Frost, why would you manipulate the EQ ratio table to get your fueling straight unless the reason your fueling was off was temperature based?
    I did have the Enable KPA set to 256 so I am assuming that it was disabled but you know what happens when you assume. With the PE Disabled I tuned the fueling based on the MAF.
    On a side note: I did have the EQ ratio set to deliver the same A/F as the MAF only tune.

    When I enabled the PE (set the enable KPA to 15) I actually expected the A/F to go rich. When it did not I "richened" the EQ Ratio in the PE table to see if it had any affect. The A/F did go richer as expected.

    I won't be changing anything on this car since it runs so well but would like to understand the nuances of HPT so blast away

  16. #96
    Senior Tuner 5_Liter_Eater's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    3,968
    You simply need to tune the upper part of the MAF table. Either put the car in open loop or use the histogram filters to filter out closed loop data and do a few WOT runs. Then use a histogram that plots the AFR error against the MAF table and copy and paste the % error directly into the MAF table (multiply by %). Attached is a histo I used on your log.

    You will need more data though as your upper MAF area you only had 1-3 hits per cell. So you need to do pulls in 3rd or 4th gear (4th is probably not feasible unless on a dyno) and you need to remove some PIDs from your config to stay under 24 bytes. Right now you're at 27. Anything over 24 bytes on your PCM cuts your framerate in half. Removing the STFT and LTFT PIDs should do it. Use different configs for different things that only contain the PIDs necessary for what you're tuning at the time.

    I would recommend that you disable the VE while tuning the MAF but since you're only concerned with >4000 RPM's here there is no need.

    And you should probably start a new thread.
    Bill Winters

    Former owner/builder/tuner of the FarmVette
    Out of the LSx tuning game

  17. #97
    Advanced Tuner
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    California
    Posts
    224
    Hey thanks very much!
    16 psi on E85