Results 1 to 8 of 8

Thread: Warm Idle Surge

  1. #1
    Tuning Addict WS6FirebirdTA00's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Concord, NC
    Posts
    8,093

    Warm Idle Surge

    I am having an odd issue on some warm starts.

    If I start up after a few hour cool down I get some surging (log attached).

    The only idle parameters changed in the factory tune was to bump up the hot idle area 100 RPM (tired of giving it too much throttle to get moving) and blended that back to the stock value at 32C/90F.

    I don't have idle control issues at any other time and after about 10 seconds of this it stabilizes.

    I notice during this time the spark, throttle position and intake valve temperatures are all fluctuating.

    This issue only happens when it has the higher startup airflow. If it starts without the adders (which I can't find in the log or tune) it does fine. In the tune the factory adaptive idle integral min is set to 0, but the other cells are -50. I see several other stock files like this. I was curious if that would have any impact, but I would expect issues elsewhere.
    Attached Files Attached Files
    Sulski Performance Tuning
    2000 WS6 M6 - LS6 (long block, refreshed top end), 10.8:1 CR, 90 mm ported FAST, Exo-Skel, 227/232 cam, QTP HVMC, EWP, GMMG, 9" w/4.11s
    2018 Sierra SLT 5.3L A8 - Airaid intake tube, GM Borla catback, L86 Intake/Ported TB

  2. #2
    Tuner Camaro6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Location
    Chicagoland
    Posts
    135
    Post the tune since a few items can do this. Stock and modified tune preferred.
    2018 Camaro SS, LT4 Fuel System, LT4 S/C
    2020 Ford Edge ST (93-E85 flex fuel tune)
    1999 Pontiac Firehawk
    1987 Chevy Caprice, 6.0L TT 4L80 AWD
    ***Only AWD box chevy in the world***
    Next Level Tuning and Performance
    Tuning email: [email protected]

  3. #3
    Tuning Addict WS6FirebirdTA00's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Concord, NC
    Posts
    8,093
    Here you go. Stock tune/reverted back to stock with just the idle speed changes. Same issues. I was trying to see if this was an issue even factory.

    It does not do it hot, it does not do it cold. It seems to only do it in the 50C-65C ECT/oil temp range.

    From what I see in the log, the spark and throttle position are constant and the RPM starts to creep up over the 1200 RPM command. Then the throttle tries to close and the spark starts to go up (less TM spark). It flares up and then seems to over correct. It goes through a few cycles and then the commanded drops from 1200. I assume this is when the startup decay expires. Then it gets into what I then assume to be adaptive idle and fixes itself as the RPM continues to lower to commanded.

    The only table I see that would impact this would be the idle external load, but I am not sure if that is active if startup hasn't fully decayed. There are some odd jumps between 1000 and 1300 RPM and also around 50C oil temperature. I tried a lower 1300 RPM value, just not a lower 1000 RPM value yet. That was going to be my next guess.

    I am not seeing any obvious tables for startup airflow, startup decay, idle spark/correction, etc. Truck is stock except for Airaid intake tube and GM Borla catback.
    Attached Files Attached Files
    Last edited by WS6FirebirdTA00; 04-17-2019 at 05:59 PM.
    Sulski Performance Tuning
    2000 WS6 M6 - LS6 (long block, refreshed top end), 10.8:1 CR, 90 mm ported FAST, Exo-Skel, 227/232 cam, QTP HVMC, EWP, GMMG, 9" w/4.11s
    2018 Sierra SLT 5.3L A8 - Airaid intake tube, GM Borla catback, L86 Intake/Ported TB

  4. #4
    Tuning Addict WS6FirebirdTA00's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Concord, NC
    Posts
    8,093
    I also noted in some 2017 files the cat warmup max ECT is 43C vs 66C in mine.

    I wonder if that could be part of this issue and also my hesitation I feel on warm restarts? It may be pushing the limits to improve emissions but hurting dravability.
    Sulski Performance Tuning
    2000 WS6 M6 - LS6 (long block, refreshed top end), 10.8:1 CR, 90 mm ported FAST, Exo-Skel, 227/232 cam, QTP HVMC, EWP, GMMG, 9" w/4.11s
    2018 Sierra SLT 5.3L A8 - Airaid intake tube, GM Borla catback, L86 Intake/Ported TB

  5. #5
    Tuner Camaro6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Location
    Chicagoland
    Posts
    135
    Quote Originally Posted by WS6FirebirdTA00 View Post
    I also noted in some 2017 files the cat warmup max ECT is 43C vs 66C in mine.

    I wonder if that could be part of this issue and also my hesitation I feel on warm restarts? It may be pushing the limits to improve emissions but hurting dravability.
    Check that your MAF is installed correctly and your CAI for any leaks (unmetered air) since it's lean when doing it and more at a higher rpm. Do you have a driving log since no MAF was changed or VE table. You should be able to keep the stock idle rpm no problem on this setup.

    You mean the car not wanting to drive on a warm restart? You have to push the pedal more to get the truck to move? It's commanding too much timing and tq mgt is engaging heavily. That's what I noticed originally when I watched the log. Try zeroing out the "Cold Launch Spark" table and see if that fixes it. Or log cold spark launch advance & time since start and see if it happens when this is engaged and alter it accordingly. It does correct at the 20sec mark, so I'm leaning towards this but make sure MAF and CAI is correct. After 158eng temp CLS doesn't effect anything.
    2018 Camaro SS, LT4 Fuel System, LT4 S/C
    2020 Ford Edge ST (93-E85 flex fuel tune)
    1999 Pontiac Firehawk
    1987 Chevy Caprice, 6.0L TT 4L80 AWD
    ***Only AWD box chevy in the world***
    Next Level Tuning and Performance
    Tuning email: [email protected]

  6. #6
    Tuner Camaro6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Location
    Chicagoland
    Posts
    135
    Also, when I went to E85 I had a bit to much air flow on cold starts and had to change the idle external load otherwise tq mgt kicked in and bounced the idle a little. On 93 with 50rpm higher it didn't do it though.
    2018 Camaro SS, LT4 Fuel System, LT4 S/C
    2020 Ford Edge ST (93-E85 flex fuel tune)
    1999 Pontiac Firehawk
    1987 Chevy Caprice, 6.0L TT 4L80 AWD
    ***Only AWD box chevy in the world***
    Next Level Tuning and Performance
    Tuning email: [email protected]

  7. #7
    Tuner Camaro6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2018
    Location
    Chicagoland
    Posts
    135
    That is how much I increased the table from stock, but I have flex fuel sensor and was due to E85. Hope all that info helps.

    IEL Chg.JPG
    2018 Camaro SS, LT4 Fuel System, LT4 S/C
    2020 Ford Edge ST (93-E85 flex fuel tune)
    1999 Pontiac Firehawk
    1987 Chevy Caprice, 6.0L TT 4L80 AWD
    ***Only AWD box chevy in the world***
    Next Level Tuning and Performance
    Tuning email: [email protected]

  8. #8
    Tuning Addict WS6FirebirdTA00's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Concord, NC
    Posts
    8,093
    Thanks for the replies.

    The MAF has been tuned, I just went back to stock to see if anything I changed in the timing tables or somewhere else may have affected it. Honestly, the only table I saw that would have any potential impact was the high octane, if that is even used around idle. I know the old calibrations did not.

    The intake tube is on good. It has the factory filter housing, so I never touched the MAF. Cold start, hot start, driving, no issues until the ECT drops back into the 50C-60C range.

    I did notice the older cals had cat warmup end at 43C ECT. Mine factory was 66C. I lowered it back down to 43C, so when the ECT is in the problem area it no longer calls for a higher idle for cat warmup.

    For the warm restart, the truck would go but it was acting like it was misfiring. The torque management timing was pulling so much (because of cat warmup) I think that was causing the feeling at very light throttle (2-4%). I also looked at the cold launch spark and was getting 0 deg the entire time.

    I was planning to make more changes to the external load table. I had some high values at 1300 RPM and this was happening at 1200 RPM. I lowered those and saw no improvement. My next shot was to attack it more and also lower the 1000 RPM area. The fact that everything was idling find outside of cat warmup in those areas, I decided to lower that as my next step. I really don't want it to idle at 1200 RPM for a minute when everything is still pretty hot.

    Do you have your stock external load table you can post or comparison?
    Sulski Performance Tuning
    2000 WS6 M6 - LS6 (long block, refreshed top end), 10.8:1 CR, 90 mm ported FAST, Exo-Skel, 227/232 cam, QTP HVMC, EWP, GMMG, 9" w/4.11s
    2018 Sierra SLT 5.3L A8 - Airaid intake tube, GM Borla catback, L86 Intake/Ported TB