Results 1 to 12 of 12

Thread: 2003 Silverado SS slow 1-2 shift at WOT

  1. #1
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16

    2003 Silverado SS slow 1-2 shift at WOT

    I am having trouble figuring out why this level 7 finishline 4l65E is taking so long to complete a 1-2 shift at WOT. Huron speed turbo kit tuning in 3 bar OS, yank 3k stall converter.
    Thanks
    2003 Chevy Silverado SS TURBO.hptss 10-30-21 4.hpl

  2. #2
    Tuning Addict blindsquirrel's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2017
    Location
    Meridian MS
    Posts
    7,646
    Don't zero out the Shift Timing tables, give them some sort of real number. .250 is a good default.

  3. #3
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by blindsquirrel View Post
    Don't zero out the Shift Timing tables, give them some sort of real number. .250 is a good default.
    Okay will definitely try that. I was under the impression that once it is modified mechanically it wouldn't matter but i will put it back report back to you. thanks

  4. #4
    Tuning Addict 5FDP's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Rogers, MN
    Posts
    13,565
    Not sure I'd completely turn off the transmission torque mngt either, leave a little in there.

    The part throttles normal tables 100% throttle position MPH does not match the full throttle shift speed normal mph either.

    Just curious as well. What injectors are those? Seems a bit odd that your VE has such low numbers for injectors that are 70lb/hr?

    Also remove the 1 bar MAP channel and add knock retard to your logs.
    2016 Silverado CCSB 5.3/6L80e, not as slow but still heavy.

    If you don't post your tune and logs when you have questions you aren't helping yourself.

  5. #5
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by 5FDP View Post
    Not sure I'd completely turn off the transmission torque mngt either, leave a little in there.

    The part throttles normal tables 100% throttle position MPH does not match the full throttle shift speed normal mph either.

    Just curious as well. What injectors are those? Seems a bit odd that your VE has such low numbers for injectors that are 70lb/hr?

    Also remove the 1 bar MAP channel and add knock retard to your logs.
    I was playing with WOT shift MPH and forgot to change the part throttle thanks you. As for injectors they are FIC 1200H, i was hitting the cylinder airmass wall when we had more boost in it so I halfed the VE, IFR and adjusted the timing tables to move the cylinder airmass down to not get the airflow code p1514.

    How much Torque mngt should i put back in it?

    I have KR in the charts but i will add to the list
    Last edited by Reckless95z; 10-30-2021 at 05:04 PM.

  6. #6
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16
    I added shift time back in, made no difference. I also added some torque management back in about 20% of what the stock was, and that made the shift even slower. I lowered the boost down to 10psi thinking it was maybe blowing through the converter. That also made no difference. It seems to be slow shifting all the time during the 1-2. I am starting to think it is not tune related and maybe a mechanical problem.
    Attached Files Attached Files

  7. #7
    Tuner
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Baton Rouge, LA
    Posts
    84
    Quote Originally Posted by Reckless95z View Post
    I added shift time back in, made no difference. I also added some torque management back in about 20% of what the stock was, and that made the shift even slower. I lowered the boost down to 10psi thinking it was maybe blowing through the converter. That also made no difference. It seems to be slow shifting all the time during the 1-2. I am starting to think it is not tune related and maybe a mechanical problem.
    Any reason why your "WOT Shift Speed vs Shift - Normal" is set the way it is? Your Upshift speeds are the same values as your Downshift speeds. Set the downshift speeds lower than the upshift speeds. This is what your latest tune file has:

    1->2 Shift: 36
    2->3 Shift: 66
    3->4 Shift: 256
    2->1 Shift: 36
    3->2 Shift: 66
    4->3 Shift: 256

    I'd change that to something like this (maybe match your Part Throttle Table's 100% Throttle values):

    1->2 Shift: 36
    2->3 Shift: 66
    3->4 Shift: 256
    2->1 Shift: 31
    3->2 Shift: 61
    4->3 Shift: 90

    As for shift timing, I've been adjusting the 1->2 on my '15 Yukon (L86/8L90) the past week. Factory configuration was disappointing. Have data logged, adjusted, logged, adjusted a few times. I've been fortunate to have great luck reducing that shift time from 1.6s (longest) down to 0.5s (as of this evening). Reducing the shift time for the desired transitions (1->2 and 2->3) in 5% reduction helped to go from 1.6s 1->2 to 0.9s. Another 5% reduction proved to be too much, so I reverted to the previous 5%, then reduced the entire table by 2%. That brought the WOT 1->2 down to 0.5s (quicker shift feel, in part throttle and WOT scenarios). I've logged three (3) WOT runs, receiving repeat results. Will leave things alone, as I'm satisfied with the results (for now). I'm NOT adjusting pressures anywhere, as this Gen has adaptive learning that adjusts pressures to "help" meet the desired, specified shift time. Can't say this'll cure your issue, but that's what'd I'd go after. We have different transmissions (obviously), but I don't have any shift time faster than 0.273s (highest torque vs RPM row of cells).

    That said... In my 24x converted 4L6xE equipped '95 Impala SS (383ci LT1 - 507hp/446lbft), my shift table is as follows:
    1->2 Shift Time: 0.325 (across the entire row)
    2->3 Shift Time: 0.300 (across the entire row)
    3->4 Shift Time: 0.275 (across the entire row)

    Before I sold the car, it was street driven (daily) in a spirited fashion (loved to catch a red light, just to beat on it). LOL Shifts were nice & firm, with absolutely no noticeable delay. Max pressure setting was 96psi.

    Good luck! ;-)
    **Capt. Ron - 7th Dist. Fire**

  8. #8
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by 1badc10 View Post
    Any reason why your "WOT Shift Speed vs Shift - Normal" is set the way it is? Your Upshift speeds are the same values as your Downshift speeds. Set the downshift speeds lower than the upshift speeds. This is what your latest tune file has:

    1->2 Shift: 36
    2->3 Shift: 66
    3->4 Shift: 256
    2->1 Shift: 36
    3->2 Shift: 66
    4->3 Shift: 256

    I'd change that to something like this (maybe match your Part Throttle Table's 100% Throttle values):

    1->2 Shift: 36
    2->3 Shift: 66
    3->4 Shift: 256
    2->1 Shift: 31
    3->2 Shift: 61
    4->3 Shift: 90

    As for shift timing, I've been adjusting the 1->2 on my '15 Yukon (L86/8L90) the past week. Factory configuration was disappointing. Have data logged, adjusted, logged, adjusted a few times. I've been fortunate to have great luck reducing that shift time from 1.6s (longest) down to 0.5s (as of this evening). Reducing the shift time for the desired transitions (1->2 and 2->3) in 5% reduction helped to go from 1.6s 1->2 to 0.9s. Another 5% reduction proved to be too much, so I reverted to the previous 5%, then reduced the entire table by 2%. That brought the WOT 1->2 down to 0.5s (quicker shift feel, in part throttle and WOT scenarios). I've logged three (3) WOT runs, receiving repeat results. Will leave things alone, as I'm satisfied with the results (for now). I'm NOT adjusting pressures anywhere, as this Gen has adaptive learning that adjusts pressures to "help" meet the desired, specified shift time. Can't say this'll cure your issue, but that's what'd I'd go after. We have different transmissions (obviously), but I don't have any shift time faster than 0.273s (highest torque vs RPM row of cells).

    That said... In my 24x converted 4L6xE equipped '95 Impala SS (383ci LT1 - 507hp/446lbft), my shift table is as follows:
    1->2 Shift Time: 0.325 (across the entire row)
    2->3 Shift Time: 0.300 (across the entire row)
    3->4 Shift Time: 0.275 (across the entire row)

    Before I sold the car, it was street driven (daily) in a spirited fashion (loved to catch a red light, just to beat on it). LOL Shifts were nice & firm, with absolutely no noticeable delay. Max pressure setting was 96psi.

    Good luck! ;-)

    I changed everything like you stated and still no luck. I did notice that the throttle is getting cut down by like 5600RPM for some reason. I am going to move all of the ETC RPM limiters up and see if its hitting one of these. I am at work right now so I dont have a log to post, but i believe you will see this in the last log i posted.

  9. #9
    Tuner
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Baton Rouge, LA
    Posts
    84
    Quote Originally Posted by Reckless95z View Post
    Okay will definitely try that. I was under the impression that once it is modified mechanically it wouldn't matter but i will put it back report back to you. thanks
    Looking back it an earlier reply, what do you mean ?modified mechanically?? Did you have FLT install a vacuum modulator? If so, that will certainly bypass any commanded shifting, relying on vacuum pressure.
    **Capt. Ron - 7th Dist. Fire**

  10. #10
    Advanced Tuner IARLLC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    943
    As a quick test of the mechanical soundness of your transmission you can lower your shift rpm and full throttle (and 100% row of part throttle) shift speed by a lot. This will at least show you if your trans is healthy. If it works out, you can raise your shift rpm more or less to the desired shift rpm and gradually ease your shift speed up until it is where you want it. Your trans might just need more lead time than it gets when things are set "accurately".

  11. #11
    Tuner in Training
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by IARLLC View Post
    As a quick test of the mechanical soundness of your transmission you can lower your shift rpm and full throttle (and 100% row of part throttle) shift speed by a lot. This will at least show you if your trans is healthy. If it works out, you can raise your shift rpm more or less to the desired shift rpm and gradually ease your shift speed up until it is where you want it. Your trans might just need more lead time than it gets when things are set "accurately".
    Quick update, the problem ended up being that the tip in retard was pulling 9 degrees of timing during the whole pull and through the shift. I logged burst knock and knock retard, for some reason knock retard was not being logged. Ended up softening the TIP in knock by 30% and now i get no knock retard during a pull and it shifts fast and firm. Thanks everyone for the help. I appreciate it.

  12. #12
    Advanced Tuner IARLLC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    943
    Thanks a lot for the update! That will help a lot of folks in the future.